Hoosier Mama Pie Company

[At pet store on same block as Hoosier.] Employee A: “I’m going to Hoosier Mama. Do you want anything?” Employee B: “I was just there.” Me: “I’m going there now. What would we do without Hoosier Mama?” We all laughed. That is what this place means to the neighborhood. It is full of heart, great food, and did I mention the ginger custard pie? Oh yeah. Pumpkin is amazing too. (I’m gluten free and love the Autumn salad and pies, minus the crust.) Just go.

Wow! What a great place with so many delicious looking options. A friend suggested Hoosier Mama Pies to me and I am glad they did. I did not know what I wanted. A 'regular' graciously made some suggestions which were spot on. Thank-you to the front end clerk Rachel for being so friendly and kind to me. Her smile really lights things up. I ended up leaving with two 6 inch pies - chocolate chess and banana cream. Both are now just delicious memories.

Stopped by after my daughter's one month check-up.Chicken pot pie was pretty good. I would've added a dash of salt but was nice and flaky. My woman got the pecan pie and it wasn't too sweet but just right. Pecans were nicely roasted and had a drizzle of chocolate. Oatmeal cookies were amazing, would love an Oatmeal cookie pie from those cookies. Unfortunately my little cutie pie couldn't have any but we'll be back when she's able.

Nice cute place with retro decor with a wide selection of pies and other sweet and savoury bakes, plus coffee and caffeine free drinks. Pies are sold whole or by slice. The lemon merengue is one of my favourite pies but I would have liked it to have a ticker crust: the base was way too think and the merengue wasn’t enough to balance the acidity.

Omg. What can I say? I thought I was a fan of chocolate pie until I had their fruit. My husband and I got 3 slices of pie, a cookie, and a handpie (lamb and apricot!). The handpie was so good, we waited in line and ordered 3 more right then and there. The girls behind the counter were working SO hard. The cashier was also making and filling the orders. Go with patience and a smile and you will be rewarded with fantastic food.

A true blast from the past vibe! The interior feels like being transported into a diner from the 50s. The seating area and shop in general is not too big, and there are two big booths that have nice big windows to people watch! The booths do get a little hot and stuffy though when the sun is bright. I adore how you could get pies by the slice here, and they have so many flavors available! I got the espresso cream and lemon chess pies, and they were delicious. The lemon chess was a classic and the espresso cream had a great balance of flavor, depth, and texture! You could also see the pie making process in the back as well! The staff were helpful and welcoming as well. Cant wait to visit again! :)

Places like Hoosier Mama Pie Company are why I’m so jealous that I don’t live in Chicago. They offer several different pie slices, mini pies, and full size pies. Savory and sweet. They also do coffee and espresso drinks. It’s just so cool that there’s a little old school pie shop with seating options to relax and enjoy a gorgeous slice. I had the cardamom blueberry and it was one of the best pieces of pie I’ve ever had. So nice on a rainy day, or a sunny day, or for no reason at all. The woman helping me was incredibly kind too. Well worth a walk or going out of your way for.